Cincinnati.Com
NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help
Currently:
80°F
Mostly Sunny
Weather | Traffic
Reds
HOME
NEWS
ENTERTAINMENT
SPORTS
REDS
BENGALS
LOCAL GUIDE
MULTIMEDIA
ARCHIVES
SEARCH
CINCINNATI REDS 
Schedule 
TV Schedule 
Game Logs 
Roster 

Reds News 
MLB News 
NL Game Capsules 
AL Game Capsules 
NL Standings 
AL Standings 

Marge Schott 
Great American 
Cinergy Field 
Joe Nuxhall 
Pete Rose 
Borgman Cartoons 
Photo Galleries 
Wallpaper 



 
Friday, September 24, 2004

Our critics speak


Viewers say Rose movie seems a bit off base

[photo]
Tom Sizemore (right) had the hairdo, but little else of his Pete Rose portrayal seemed accurate to the Enquirer's panel of Hustle viewers.
Provided/ESPN

On Saturday night, ESPN will debut its movie Hustle, which chronicles the downfall of Reds great Pete Rose. Hustle centers on the relationship between Rose (played by Tom Sizemore) and Paul Janszen (Dash Mihok), the man who told Major League Baseball about Rose's gambling habits. The Enquirer held an advance screening for four readers; here's what they had to say.

Did the movie change your views on Pete Rose at all?

Dan DeVoe (Miami Township): I don't think it shed any new light, and we're definitely slanted in Cincinnati. I've been a fan of Pete all my life, and you can't help but feel the way you feel.

Andrea Henderson (West Chester): I knew going in that this would present a one-sided view, and it had a one-sided feel, so I'm not going to take everything in the movie as gospel.

Brady Melton (College Hill): When I watched the movie, I felt sorry for him. I saw someone who was being challenged by demons. And to feed those demons, he surrounded himself with weak people.

Jim Todd (Fort Mitchell): It was definitely slanted. It was based on the Dowd Report. So it's basically Paul's (Paul Janszen's) story. And that's not really anything new.
POST YOUR REVIEWS
Come back after you've seen the movie Saturday night to post your thoughts and comments on the movie.

How do you think Paul Janszen was portrayed?

Dan DeVoe (Miami Township): In everything I've read, I've never thought of him as a dim bulb. And that's how he's portrayed.

Andrea Henderson (West Chester): This almost portrays him as a flawed good guy, because it is from his perspective.

Brady Melton (College Hill): I saw him as someone who tried his best, but when he was pushed up against the wall, he did what he had to do.

Jim Todd (Fort Mitchell): They want you to be sympathetic toward him, and that's not the way it really should be.

What do you feel was inaccurate?

Dan DeVoe (Miami Township): Pete was an athlete. He wasn't that fat. He didn't walk with a hunch.

Andrea Henderson (West Chester): The voice was wrong. Pete didn't talk like that.

Brady Melton (College Hill): Marge Schott was way off. They could have found someone much better to play her.

Jim Todd (Fort Mitchell): They showed his competitiveness during the gambling scenes, but they didn't show it during the baseball scenes.

What did you like?

Dan DeVoe (Miami Township): (You can see) where the public outcry came from. (The movie makers) didn't show the fans and their reaction, but they showed you why the fans felt the way they did.

Andrea Henderson (West Chester): The hair was right on, but they used it as a prop almost. They put a wig on him and said, "If the hair's there, it's Pete Rose."

Brady Melton (College Hill): Pete's description about how he played baseball, during his speech, when he applies that to why he gambled. That was accurate. (In the speech, Rose talks about how he wasn't afraid to take risks on the field, which made him great.)

Jim Todd (Fort Mitchell): They showed the part about there being no finding by Baseball that Pete bet on baseball, then (Commissioner Bart) Giamatti turning around and saying he didn't believe that. They showed that Pete got shorted on the deal.

Would this movie be more effective as a straight documentary?

Dan DeVoe (Miami Township): So much of his life during this time was behind closed doors. It had to be dramatized.

Andrea Henderson (West Chester): Without a doubt.

Brady Melton (College Hill): (Yes). It was way too simplistic. They bang you over the head with the point instead of letting you think for yourself.

Jim Todd (Fort Mitchell): In that way, they could have continued on with a lot of things that weren't touched on in the movie.

- Ryan Ernst




BENGALS
Bengals rush toward changes
Patterson joins team roster

FANTASY FOOTBALL
Difficult decisions at RB

KY. PREP SPORTS
Teams on the climb
Weekend Preview: N. Ky. Top Games At A Glance
Prep football player of year
CovCath chases another golf title
Long time coming

OHIO PREP SPORTS
QBs at forefront
Weekend Preview: Ohio Top Games At A Glance
Prep football player of year
No. 2 no longer
Conference titles are on the line for golfers
Braves get by short-handed Madeira
Prep results, schedule

DAUGHERTY COLUMN
Daugherty: Reds' minor leagues a mess

REDS
Our critics speak on Rose film
Janszen says film has foibles
Reds Hall open Saturday
Hudson a shining spot in gloomy Cincinnati season
Next season may find Acevedo in bullpen

MORE BASEBALL
Maddux rings up 15th win of season
Olympics qualifying changes for 2008

UC BEARCATS
Bearcats' Benton stands out in crowd of RBs

COLLEGE SPORTS
It's all about the arm

TV
Sports today on TV, radio

Return to Reds front page...

Email this story to a friend




 
REDS NEWSLETTER
Subscribe to the Cincinnati.Com Reds Report.
Cincinnati.Com
Search our site by keyword:  

Search also: News | Jobs | Homes | Cars | Classifieds | Obits | Coupons | Events | Dining
Movies/DVDs | Video Games | Hotels | Golf | Visitor's Guide | Maps/Directions | Yellow Pages

  CINCINNATI.COM  |  NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help
Copyright 1995-2007. The Cincinnati Enquirer, a Gannett Co. Inc. newspaper.
Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service (updated December 19, 2002).