Cincinnati.Com
NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help
Currently:
22°F
Cloudy
Weather | Traffic
Reds
HOME
NEWS
ENTERTAINMENT
SPORTS
REDS
BENGALS
LOCAL GUIDE
MULTIMEDIA
ARCHIVES
SEARCH
CINCINNATI REDS 
Schedule 
TV Schedule 
Game Logs 
Roster 

Reds News 
MLB News 
NL Game Capsules 
AL Game Capsules 
NL Standings 
AL Standings 

Marge Schott 
Great American 
Cinergy Field 
Joe Nuxhall 
Pete Rose 
Borgman Cartoons 
Photo Galleries 
Wallpaper 



 
Thursday, October 16, 2003

Fan deserves pity, not scorn



map
Steve Bartman is the 26-year-old Cubs fan who robbed Moises Alou of a foul flyout in the eighth inning Tuesday night. The incident sent the Cubbies' psyches spinning out of alignment and turned what should have been a World Series celebration into another evening of soul torture.

The Cubs are always nine toes off the ledge anyway. They and their passionate, neurotic fans don't need another reason to jump.

On Tuesday, Steve Bartman must have been thinking: "Front-row seat. Left-field line. Cool. Maybe I'll get a foul ball."

On Wednesday, Bartman was the most hated man in Chicago.

Three words for Stevie: Passport. Sunglasses. Nepal.

But, really.

Honestly.

If you were Bartman, you'd have done the same thing. You'd have stuck out your hand and tried to catch the ball. You wouldn't be thinking, "One out, one on, eighth inning, Cubs up 3-0, Cubs five outs from their first World Series in 58 years, I think I'll duck so Moises can try to grab this foul ball." Nope.

You'd say, "Get outta my way, loser, I'm catching this baseball."

You would. Because you are a fan, and in moments such as that, fans are not rational.

Come to think of it, fans are never rational.

That's why fans celebrate world titles and beating Michigan by burning cars. It's why Steve Bartman left Tuesday's game in the bottom of the eighth, coat wrapped around his head, ducking beer showers. Nobody who's rational throws a $6 beer at someone. A $2 beer, maybe.

We realize that these days, fans make a larger emotional investment in their teams than players or management do. We've never seen Mike Brown paint his face orange and black. We know the joy winning brings.

But come on.

The guy did nothing wrong. He tried to catch a foul ball. The ball was out of play. He had to leave with a security escort. He couldn't show his face Wednesday. That ain't right.

The ballpark is where we're supposed to enjoy ourselves. We check our anger at the turnstile. We don't bring in the hostility baggage. It's not a ballplayer's fault (or a fan's) if our lives stink.

Only now, maybe it is.

"It follows a general psychological premise," said David Hellkamp, a Xavier psychology professor and a consulting sports psychologist. "It's easier to blame someone else for your disappointment with the Cubs."

We asked Hellkamp to weigh in because Cubs' fans are A Beautiful Mind, multiplied by millions. What happened to them Tuesday will be studied for centuries. What happened to Bartman could have happened to anyone.

If the Cubs aren't in the World Series, Bartman is in physical and emotional danger. If they are, he's on Leno Friday night.

"It was typical" fan behavior, said Kevin Grace, a UC assistant professor and sports historian. He teaches a course, The Social History of Baseball, in which he shows students a cartoon from a Cincinnati newspaper, depicting an umpire in armor and angry fans chasing him. It's from '85. 1885.

"If the fans had left (Bartman) alone, I'd have been surprised," Grace said.

Bartman might be a symptom of a century of Cubdom. But he didn't cost them the game. Lousy pitching, managing and defense did.

Fans could stand to apply the emotional brakes. A game is just that.

E-mail pdaugherty@enquirer.com




NLCS: MARLINS 9, CUBS 6
Marlins stun Cubs, head to World Series
Rodriguez finds redemption's sweet
Marlins happy to be spoilers
Wood blames himself: 'I choked'
DAUGHERTY: Fan deserves pity, not scorn
Fan apologizes for preventing catch
Sad Cubs fans will have to wait 'til next year

ALCS: RED SOX 9, YANKEES 6
Pedro vs. Clemens: Winner take all
Boston's bats come alive in nick of time

REDS
Prokopec rejects Reds' Triple-A offer

BENGALS-NFL
Lewis debates Dillon's status
Receiving corps could benefit from big boost
NFL Notebook: Plummer out, Beuerlein starts

COLLEGE BASKETBALL
Miami Basketball Preview

COLLEGE FOOTBALL
Ohio State's Gamble loses glitz
Nance now Miami's top offensive threat
Marshall awaits C-USA invitation

HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL
Chat today: Elder coach Doug Ramsey, noon to 12:30 p.m. at Cincinnati.com
Injury can't stop NewCath's Smith

OTHER HIGH SCHOOL SPORTS
Field hockey has local growth spurt
Soccer tournament highlights
Wednesday's results | Today's schedule
Cross country polls

NBA
Bryant hearing comes to close

LOCAL SPORTS
Sports on TV-Radio

Return to Reds front page...

Email this story to a friend


 
REDS NEWSLETTER
Subscribe to the Cincinnati.Com Reds Report.
Cincinnati.Com
Search our site by keyword:  

Search also: News | Jobs | Homes | Cars | Classifieds | Obits | Coupons | Events | Dining
Movies/DVDs | Video Games | Hotels | Golf | Visitor's Guide | Maps/Directions | Yellow Pages

  CINCINNATI.COM  |  NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help
Copyright 1995-2007. The Cincinnati Enquirer, a Gannett Co. Inc. newspaper.
Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service (updated December 19, 2002).