Monday, March 31, 2003

Small, minority, women-owned contractors got share of ballpark


Priority for Hamilton County: Project had own consultant

By John Eckberg
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Darraugh Butler
Darraugh Butler, president of D. Butler Management Consulting , worked with the Great American Ball Park construction team to identify and include minority businesses in the construction.

(Enquirer file photo)
| ZOOM |
When the Great American Ball Park opens to its first regular-season game this afternoon, tens of thousands of baseball fans are not likely to realize the role played by the region's small and medium-sized businesses.

A majority of the infrastructure and parking improvements at the new ballpark, for instance, came from the drawing boards of small businesses or businesses owned by minorities or women, according to statistics compiled by Hamilton County.

Elsewhere on the project, they accounted for:

• Sixty percent of the $12.9 million east parking garage.

• Sixty percent of the $17.1 million site improvement contract.

• Thirty-seven percent of the $214 million spent on the ballpark itself.

• Ninety-three percent of the $8.5 million for contract management.

"We did better than with Paul Brown Stadium," said Bernice L. Walker, director of small, minority and female business development for Hamilton County.

"One of the reasons was the program was new on this project and we had a small business consultant right on the job site. That helped out a lot. It got good and accurate information to the small businesses interested in working with us."

Showing an interest in the work, actually seeking it, is always going to be a critical first step for any small enterprise on a big job like the ballpark.

Lisa Rowell, an engineer and principal with Infrastructure Services Inc., an Akron-based company with offices in Blue Ash, says that without initiative, a company might just as well pack it in.

"It's all about networking and marketing," Rowell said. "You have to be proactive to get the work. If you're proactive in your approach, you have a better opportunity to get additional services for your company."

Infrastructure Services handled all topographical surveys for the site, as well as assisting with concrete testing and other administrative support. Eight are employed in the local office.

James Clingman, principal with Triad Development LLC, a project development and business consulting group based in Springdale, is not so sure that minority companies did any better with Great American Ball Park than at Paul Brown Stadium.

After all, he said, Cincinnati's minority population is at 45 percent and growing.

"I don't want a number for minorities," he said. "I want a number for blacks, and I was told it was 11 percent. Now my question is what does it represent? And these are jobs that are no longer there because the park is finished."

He said raw numbers can conceal reality. For instance, a minority electrical supplier at Paul Brown Stadium received a $146,000 contract on a job but pocketed only $3,500.

"That guy is just serving as a pass-through," he said.

Clingman is keeping his eyes peeled for continuing work at the stadium: The suppliers of restroom materials, the vendors, the suppliers of food items.

The county did not break out participation along ethnic lines for Great American Ball Park, said Sonya Walton, small business coordinator for D. Butler Management Consulting, a downtown group hired to oversee the county's small business participation.

"We were not even required to break out the numbers along minority lines, but we did it anyway," she said.

"The goal was a small-business goal. Still, we decided it was in our best interest to break out the minority numbers to show that we are being inclusive."

She estimated that black-owned businesses received about 10 percent of the work.

This time around, the county took precautions in an effort to curtail pass-through companies working at Great American Ball Park. Companies had to be certified by an agency that they were not pass-through companies.

"The process is very, very tedious," she said.

Letters of intent were collected to ensure that prime contractors were committed to using small businesses. Forms showing payout, contract values and remaining work were monitored monthly, she said.

"I do that for every single contractor. At one time, there were 45 or 50," she said. "People need to understand what we did to ensure inclusion."

Also, authorities sought out small businesses before the first shovelful of dirt was moved.

Before construction, Phillip Bunton, principal at Bunton and Associates, was hired to compile a database from local groups concerned with small-business issues of all small and medium-sized businesses in the region.

The database was used as a contact list for companies that had expertise in areas that were about to be bid.

"It was absolutely a proactive approach. It was a way of measuring capacity of the small business community," he said

Walton said that as leaders grapple with a new convention center project, estimated at $160 million, executives and minority companies need to put the past behind them.

"I understand the frustration people feel with Paul Brown Stadium because it was not fair. But people need to look forward, not dwell in the past and move forward," Walton said.

---

E-mail jeckberg@enquirer.com.




OPENING DAY IN CINCINNATI
10-1 loss spoils Opening Day
Game PhotosParade photos
Poll: Grade the stadium
New ballpark adds to thrill
Opening Day warms our soul
Parade map and street closings
Going to the game? Get there early
Answers to other fan questions
Public art project swings into action

ABOUT THE REDS
Fans unwrap new park, team
In new ballparks, Casey's a big hit
Reds in slump as they open new park
Rose has lost little support from public

GREAT AMERICAN BALL PARK
Photo gallery
Fan verdicts mostly raves
A clubhouse to call his own
Ballpark ready to go after smooth test runs
Reds ticket sales off to sluggish start
Reds fans welcomed by hotels
Small, minority, women-owned contractors got share of ballpark
Luxury seats steal home from telecasts
Banner flyers grounded and grumbling

OTHER BASEBALL
A-Rod, Texas upstage Anaheim
Games with backdrop of war
Cone wins spot in Mets' rotation
Baseball notebook

HEART MINI-MARATHON
Lentz cruises to his first Mini-Marathon victory
Tranter takes fourth straight women's title
Senator addresses walk participants
Heart Mini-Marathon top results

COLLEGE BASKETBALL
Syracuse crushes Oklahoma for spot in Final Four
Horns only No. 1 to advance
Estill's return would solidify veteran UK lineup
Somebody's time to shine has come
Orangemen's Boeheim has chance to avenge smarting loss
One No. 1 seed, one repeater in Final Four
Has deciding NCAA game already been played?
Marquette has inspiration on the bench
NCAA tournament notebook
NKU's effort leaves coach with tears of pride
Women: UConn, Purdue advance in East

GOLF
Love roars to TPC win with closing 8-under 64
Meunier-Lebouc denies Sorenstam bid

HOCKEY
Cyclones open ECHL playoffs at Peoria

NASCAR
Newman gambles for lead, beats Little E

NBA
Carter sticks it to Knicks with 28

TENNIS
Agassi wins sixth Key Biscayne title

PREP SPORTS
Monday's prep sports schedule

PLAN YOUR DAY
Monday's sports on TV, radio

Return to Reds front page...