By DAN BICKLEY
The Arizona Republic
One day, a Super Bowl champion will be crowned on its ability to peer into the future. Coming soon, a World Series will be decided in July, and the most valuable players will be ballot-box stuffers and players who actually take the All-Star Game seriously.
Incredibly, in the 21st century, a couple of billion-dollar industries are priming themselves for tremendous embarrassment.
Of course, you expect this kind of folly from major league baseball and its wacky commissioner. One only hopes that Bud Selig understands what's at stake in handing the All-Star Game winner instant home-field advantage in the ensuing World Series.
After all, since 1982, there have been eight World Series that featured a Game 7, and the home team prevailed every time.
While it's certainly better than the sleepy alternative - the two leagues had simply alternated home-field advantage every year since 1903 - this new proposal could lend itself to some dicey situations:
What if fans elect a player who is extremely popular yet in the midst of a horrendous season, as they often did with Cal Ripken Jr.? And what if that player commits a key error that costs his league a nifty advantage come October?
What happens if a stud such as Randy Johnson decides it is better to nurse a sore back, as he did last season?
As you can see, there's a lot of juice riding on an exhibition game.
In the case of the NFL, you expect a little more clarity and reason. If nothing else, you don't expect a team to play 17 games and then watch a season circle the drain because of a coin flip.
But that's what happened to the Steelers last week in Tennessee. It could have happened in last year's Super Bowl, a game that seemed destined for overtime. It could have happened in the conference championships, except that neither game was close to a tie.
As parity consumes the NFL, the league must adopt a new way of settling tied games.
This season, a record 26 games have gone into overtime. That number will only continue to rise as the league becomes more and more homogenized.
Of those 26 games, 11 were decided on one possession, meaning the losing team never touched the ball. While that percentage is down from previous years, when it was about a 50-50 split, that's far too many losses determined by the flip of a coin.
Twice this season, a team scored on a drive at the end of regulation and then prevailed on the first possession of overtime. Playing defense on successive possessions at the end of a 60-minute game is an impossible assignment for the best of teams.
The Raiders lost twice in overtime without touching the ball. In other years, that could have cost them home-field advantage in the playoffs.
In Week 7 Detroit won a coin flip and scored on the first possession to beat Chicago. In their rematch five weeks later, Detroit won the coin flip again and Lions coach Marty Mornhinweg inexplicably gave the ball to the Bears.
Naturally, the Bears prevailed on their first possession, too, and Mornhinweg was about as popular in Detroit as imported cars.
Anyone who saw the Fiesta Bowl realizes the National Collegiate Athletic Association's way of settling ties is far more equitable. Anyone who saw Arkansas' 58-56 win over Mississippi in 2001 - the game was tied 17-17 after four quarters before stretching to seven overtimes - knows how exciting that system can be.
So take the college premise and tailor it to the professional game, such as giving each team a possession at midfield. Or require teams to score six points in overtime, thus avoiding the quick field goal and y'all drive home safely.
Just do something that doesn't require a piece of change. And hope that we have seen enough coin flips for one season.
After all, three of the past four NFL games played at Qualcomm Stadium went to overtime, the same building that will host Super Bowl XXXVII.
Have a nice day.
BENGALS
Bengals hire Hayes, complete new staff
Packers hire Bengals' Duffner
SUPER BOWL XXXVII
Daugherty: Raiders lacking in loose cannons
Middleton ready to renew battle with Sapp
With Gruden, it's Super Bowl or bust
Sapp relishes spotlight
Davis, Raiders inflame NFL passions
Callahan following Wizard to Oz
Bucs' safety defies stereotyping
With shot at 2nd ring, Buc comes full circle
Big Brother takes over Super Bowl security
Glazers keep a low profile - usually
Sting, Twain, No Doubt headline halftime show
Survivor Gannon came a long way
Super Bowl Notebook
Super Bowl quotes
Enquirer panel will rate SB ads
OTHER NFL NEWS
Still the one: Vet NFL's worst field
NFL notebook
BASEBALL
Baseball, football set selves up for humiliation
Rose owes $150,000 in back taxes
Rose watch: No word yet, just meetings
Biggio requests extension from Astros
COLLEGE BASKETBALL
Huggins misses practice to be with ailing mother
Musketeers finally finding mark on offense
XU women enjoy turnaround season
Gillen wins war of ex-Xs
No. 10 Creighton gets Aced
Smith hopes Knight passes him
College basketball notebook
AUSTRALIAN OPEN
Agassi eases to Aussie final
Serena Slam bid alive
Australian Open notebook
GOLF
Sorenstam ponders PGA Tour possibilities
Health problems forgotten, Frazar leads tournament
NBA
Yao Ming to start; Garnett edges Nowitzki
NBA life rougher when games are back-to-back
HOCKEY
Sundstrom, McLaren in 3-team swap
Dunham wins in first Nashville road trip
Hockey Today
PREP SPORTS
Riverfest Rumble organizers in trouble
Princeton gets tests in bid for top seed
Ohio girls games
Kentucky boys games
Kentucky girls games
Winton Woods leaps into FAVC contention
Fairfield hasn't skipped a beat without Smith
St. Henry, Brossart big favorites for All 'A'
Madden embraces Boone's team leader role
Enquirer/Channel 9 Player of the Year
Walnut Hills hosts tourney
Classic possible preview of postseason
Competitive Vadney discovers niche
Thunderhawks hang tough, but Firebirds prevail
Wrestling: Milford's Costello has plan to keep up numbers
Prep hoops schedule
Swimming results
Wrestling results, schedule
PLAN YOUR DAY
Sports today on TV, radio
Return to Reds front page...